6126 Hollywood Boulevard: Music Box Theatre

The Music Box Theatre c. 1928. Note the KNX radio transmission tower (1 of 2) on the roof of the Hoffman Studebaker building next door at 6116 Hollywood Boulevard. USC digital photo.

This theater on the south side of Hollywood Boulevard in the midst of Hollywood Automobile Row opened on October 20, 1926 as Carter DeHaven’s Music Box. Unlike the Marcal, which had opened five months earlier just to the east at 6025 Hollywood Boulevard, the Music Box started out as a legitimate theater, not a movie theater venue.

 

Hollywood Daily Citizen 9/12/1925.

The project was announced in the Hollywood Daily Citizen on September 12, 1925 and in the Los Angeles Illustrated Daily news and the Los Angeles Times on September 12, 1925.

The land the theater was built on, like Hoffman Studebaker’s, was leased from the estate of Daeida (Ida) Beveridge. Often called the “Mother of Hollywood,” she had owned the large ranch property with her husband, Harvey Henderson Wilcox. The couple came to the area from Topeka, Kansas and subdivided Hollywood in 1887. Wilcox passed away in 1891; in 1892, Ida married Philo Beveridge. Ida Beveridge controlled the Wilcox land holdings and, when Hollywood incorporated in 1903, donated land for many of its civic buildings. She passed away in 1914 and her estate manager, C.B. Brunson (who was married to the Beveridge’s daughter Phyllis), developed the property as Hollywood turned increasingly commercial.

The theater was to be a legitimate show house, venue for musical revues in the style of Flo Ziegfeld, George White and Earl Carroll on Broadway- and was probably influenced by the “Music Box Revue” shows presented by Irving Berlin and Sam S. Harris between 1921 and 1924 at Berlin’s Music Box Theatre. The project proponents were actor Carter DeHaven (also spelled de Haven), who was to run the theater, and William S. Holman, secretary of the Christie Film Company, one of the earliest movie studios in Hollywood. The architect was Morgan, Walls & Clements. The building also contained four retail spaces and an open-air cabaret space on the roof.

LA Illustrated Daily News 9/13/1925.

Carter DeHaven was a Vaudeville/Broadway stage actor who later appeared in motion pictures, often with his wife, Flora Parker (typically billed as “Mrs. Carter DeHaven”). The couple’s daughter, Gloria DeHaven later also joined the acting profession.

Hollywood’s elite paid $11 a seat to attend the gala grand opening on October 20, 1926. The opening show was called “Fancies.” Though local theater critics raved about the show, “the most brilliant premiere in the history of California” was not without its hiccups. Journalist Dan Thomas in his syndicated column, “These Movie Folk,” wrote that “first-nighters were given more than they expected. In the second act, the stage was adorned with settings from two different scenes, which didn’t match at all. I am told that all of the stagehands were- well, intoxicated.”

“Everyone who is anyone will be there.” LA Times 10/20/1926.

Hollywood Citizen News 10/21/1926.

Carter DeHaven’s association with the running of the theater was short. In January 1927 Louis O. Macloon took it over. His first show, “Hollywood Music Box Revue,” opened February 2, 1927. In March, the show, renamed the “Fanny Brice Revue,” moved to the Biltmore Theatre downtown.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 2/1/1927.

LA Times 3/15/1927.

In February 1928, George Sherwood took out a long lease on the theater. His first production was “Women Go On Forever,” which had run on Broadway at the Forrest Theatre from September to December 1927, opened at the Music Box March 13, 1928.

Under George Sherwood. LA Evening Express 3/15/1928.

After “Women Go On Forever” closed in May 1928, Sherwood engaged the Pasadena Community Players’ production of “Lazarus Laughed,” by Eugene O’Neill to be performed at the Music Box for a limited engagement starting May 15, 1928. If anyone came expecting to laugh, they would be very confused.

LA Times 5/6/1928

LA Times 5/12/1928.

“Lazarus Laughed” closed on May 31 and the Music Box went dark until June 18, when the Japanese Imperial Theater Players opened with a Ken-Geki show- Japanese sword play with music and dancing- for a limited 1-week engagement, sponsored by L.E Behymer and Hollywood elites Charlie Chaplin, Sid Grauman, Sam Goldwin, Cecil B. DeMille and Joseph M. Schenck.

LA Evening Express 6/13/1928

In July 1928, Max Dill of the comedy team Kolb and Dill took over the Music Box lease. His first production, a musical comedy written by Dill himself called “Pair O’ Docs,” opened August 22, 1928. It featured a chorus of young women performing in roller skates. The show- and Max Dill- moved to the Mayan Theatre on September 16, 1928.

LA Times 8/19/1928

Dixie McCoy, former head of casting at the Christie movie studio, took over the theater’s lease on September 7, 1928. She intended it as a venue for her own production company, to offer a series of dramas starting with Gilbert Emery’s play “Tarnish,” which had run on Broadway at the Belmont Theater from October 1923 to May 1924. McCoy’s production opened at the Music Box on September 25, 1928 and closed November 4. Although McCoy had indicated in October that she would be announcing further productions for the Music Box “soon,” instead she announced that she was moving her production company to the Vine Street Theater at 1615 N. Vine.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 9/25/1928.

The Music Box went dark on November 5-15, 1928. On November 14, a documentary-style film, “Simba,” opened at the theater for a limited 10-day run November 16-25. It had already played for several weeks downtown at the Biltmore Theatre.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 11/15/1928.

The Music Box went dark again from November 26 to December 24, 1928. On December 25, comedian and ex-Ziegfeld star Lupino Lane appeared at the Music Box for a limited engagement over the holidays, returning the theater to its musical revue format. Lane had previously appeared in the Music Box Revue show in 1927 while it was still under the management of Carter DeHaven. The popular show closed February 4.

LA Evening Express 12/25/1928.

The Music Box went dark after Lane’s show for the rest of February and all but one day of March 1928. On Easter Sunday, March 31, flamboyant young evangelist Rheba Crawford held services in the theater. Though it was an invitation-only event for the main floor, the balcony was thrown open to the public.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 3/29/1929.

Crawford had begun her career with the Salvation Army, attending rallies in Times Square, New York, where she earned the nickname “The Angel of Broadway.” Crawford quit the Salvation Army in January 1923 after a high-profile incident in which she backed up traffic on the famous thoroughfare. She came to Los Angeles in January 1929 and began preaching over radio station KPLA. In 1934 she would become an assistant pastor at Sister Aimee Semple McPherson’s Angelus Temple.

O. D. Woodward took on a 5-year lease for the Music Box in March 1929. His first production, a frothy comedy, “The High Road,” opened on April 13.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 4/6/1929.

On May 19, 1929, “Dracula” opened at Woodward’s Music Box, starring Bela Lugosi. Lugosi had portrayed the Count during the show’s original Broadway run at the Fulton Theater from October 1927 to May 1928. He had reprised the role at the Biltmore Theatre in the Summer of 1928, also staged by O. D. Woodward. A motion picture version was released in 1931.

LA Times 5/19/1929.

On June 19, 1929, Monroe Lathrop, arts writer for the Los Angeles Evening Express, reported that theatrical producer/composer Harry Carroll had signed a long term lease for the Music Box and would take it over on or around September 15, 1929. His first show, “Harry Carroll’s Revue,” was in keeping with the Music Box’s not-so-distant roots.

As Harry Carroll’s. LA Record 9/17/1929.

On September 26, 1929, Ralph G. Farnum, New York casting agent, borrowed the Music Box for the day to hold auditions for performers to populate Broadway shows by Ziegfeld, George White, Earl Carroll, George M. Cohen and others. The turnabout was seen as fair play, as Hollywood, since the recent advent of talking pictures, was increasingly poaching talent from the Broadway stage for its all-singing, all-dancing musicals that featured Broadway-style reviews- such as Warner Brothers’ Gold Diggers of Broadway (1929).

Harry Carroll’s Revue closed on October 22 and the theater went dark again. On November 12, 1929, the LA Evening Express reported the unfortunate news that, per the trade publication Inside Facts, Carroll had had to sell his $30,000 house in Santa Monica to pay off debts incurred by the show. The only time the Music Box was not dark that month was on November 19 when Fox did some night shooting for a talkie at the entrance to the theater, attracting a huge crowd on the Boulevard.

On December 23, 1929, The Music Box reopened with a 1-off play, a comedy farce written by Clarence O’Dell Miller- a prominent Pasadena attorney- and Ole M. Ness- former director of the Potboiler art group- called “Maternally Yours.”

LA Record 12/20/1929.

The show was not well received by critics and even stunts like a local dairy distributing bottles of milk in the aisles and co-author Miller mailing personal cards and letters inviting everyone in the LA phone book named Miller to attend “Miller Night,” it was a flop. Though a New Years’ Eve matinee had been advertised, the show closed abruptly and the theater slapped together a vaudeville program with fun galore, girls and free dancing.

LA Evening Express 12/31/1929.

In January 1930 the Los Angeles Repertory Theater, renamed the Civic Repertory Theater, took over the Music Box for its new season. The first of 8 plays, “And So To Bed,” opened January 27, 1930. The successful season concluded in June, after which the theater would host special events such as dance recitals.

LA Evening Express 1/27/1930.

The Edith Jane School held its Spring 1930 recital at the Hollywood Music Box. For more information on Edith Jane (later Falcon Studios) see my posts here and here. LA Times 6/8/1930.

Agnes De Mille put on a recital at the Music Box also. LA Record 7/9/1930.

Later in the Summer of 1930, Hollywood Civic leaders organized the Hollywood Bowl Theater Association and planned to build a theater at the Bowl. The Civic Repertory Theater would be its company. Meanwhile, it remained at the Music Box, where the Fall season opened November 3, 1930, with George Bernard Shaw’s “The Apple Cart.” Profits from the season were to go toward building the company’s permanent home at the Bowl. The 1930-31 season began strong on January 5, 1931, with “Porgy.” But the Bowl plans never materialized and the company had to end the season early due to lack of financial support; through an arrangement the Pasadena Community Playhouse, subscribers were able to attend that venue’s plays on certain nights.

LA Times 1/5/1931.

Parking lot to the west of the theater c. January 1931 when “Porgy” was on. LAPL photo.

Dickson Morgan used the suddenly dark theater to bring Leslie Carter to Hollywood in “Shanghai Gesture” for a limited engagement starting April 20, 1931. It was a critical and commercial success. Miriam Hopkins would portray Carter in a 1940 biopic “The Lady with Red Hair.”

LA Times 4/19/1931.

When “Shanghai Gesture” closed, the Music Box went dark except for the odd special event. It was by no means unique in this. Other Hollywood legitimate theaters were experiencing long periods of vacancies as well. One could blame the Depression, or the novelty of talking pictures; however, hit shows proved audiences would come if given fare they liked and stayed away in droves if they didn’t like a show.

They didn’t like Morgan’s next show, “Precedent,” which opened at the Music Box September 21, 1931. The creme of Hollywood motion picture society turned up for the first night but after that it was sparsely attended and closed October 3. Morgan had reportedly already taken on a long-term lease on the Music Box.

LA Illustrated Daily News 9/21/1931.

The Music Box went dark again, reopening Christmas Day 1931 with a French farce, “Easy for Zee Zee,” produced by Richard Wilbur, which had run for 61 weeks at the Green Street Theater in San Francisco, interrupted by police raids. The racy fare attracted capacity audiences through January into February. On Feb 6, 1932, cast members Virginia King and Harry J. Jordan got married on stage at the conclusion of the performance and invited the audience to attend. The show closed on February 8, 1932.

“Big stage wedding tonight.” LA Times 2/6/1932.

The Music Box was now under the management of Richard Wilbur, whose stock company, the Wilbur Players, promised a new play every Friday starting February 19, 1932, with “It’s a Wise Child.”

LA Illustrated Daily News 2/19/1932.

The players did stage 4 plays on 4 successive Fridays but despite reports that the box office was booming, the theater closed abruptly without explanation.

On April 26, 1932, a 1-off production of “Hit the Air,” a musical spoof on radio (the latest threat to Hollywood), produced by Harry M. Sugarman, opened at the Music Box. Sugarman, aka “Sugie” would later open The Tropics, a South Seas-themed cocktail lounge in Beverly Hills, and the Hollywood Tropics on Vine Street (see my post on the Hawaiian Craze).

LA Times 4/26/1932.

This pattern of different short-term operators or stock companies leasing the theater for their productions would be repeated for the rest of the 1930s and the first half of the 1940s. A notable tenant was CBS radio, which used the theater for Lux broadcasts from 1936 to 1940. CBS would also use other Hollywood legitimate theaters (such as the Vine Street Theater at 1615 N. Vine) for different broadcasts even after its new West Coast headquarters opened on Sunset Boulevard, as the Movie Town became the Radio City, but 6126 Hollywood Boulevard was the home of Lux Radio Theater for its first 5 years in Hollywood.

Lux Radio Theater, sponsored by Lever Brothers (makers of the popular detergent and bath soap Lux), began broadcasting from New York on October 14, 1934 over the NBC Blue Network, presenting adaptations of Broadway plays dramatized by stage actors as well as visiting film stars. Lever Bros. had long featured film’s leading ladies in its beauty soap print advertisements so already had ties to Hollywood.

Monday, June 1, 1936 marked several firsts for the show: its move to CBS, to Hollywood, and the Music Box Theater. It began dramatizing movies rather than plays, often featuring the original stars reprising their roles. Cecil B. DeMille served as director, producer and narrator.

The historic June 1, 1936 show was “The Legionnaire and the Lady,” an adaptation of the 1930 film “Morocco.” Marlene Dietrich performed her original role with Clark Gable stepping into Gary Cooper’s shoes. Gable had appeared on the Music Box stage before- in a 1927 production of “Chicago.” The Lux radio show was broadcast in front of a live studio audience and a capacity crowd filled the Music Box, though local arts critics lamented that radio theater was not theatre.

The September 1936 issue of Radio Mirror speculated whether Hollywood would glamorize radio following Lux Radio Theater’s move to the West Coast. Clark Gable, Marlene Dietrich and C.B. DeMille during the production of “The Legionnaire and the Lady” are pictured in the upper left. In the lower left are William Powell and Myrna Loy, who would appear the following Monday, June 8, 1936, in Lux’s second Hollywood broadcast, reprising their roles as Nick and Nora Charles in an adaptation of their 1934 film “The Thin Man.” via Lantern.

 

Lux Radio Theater celebrated its 6th calendar year in 1939. Hollywood Citizen News 1/12/1939.

 

In the Summer of 1940, the Music Box Theatre resumed use as a legitimate show house. The Hollywood Theater Alliance, formerly headquartered in the old Writers Club building at 6700 Sunset Boulevard, took on a 5 year lease of the theater and moved in on August 1, 1940. Its first production here, “Meet the People” debuted on August 19, when it moved to the Music Box from the Hollywood Playhouse on Vine.

Hollywood Citizen News 8/15/1940.

The Music Box continued to be used as a legitimate theater by others through the Summer of 1944.

The Duncan Sisters attempted unsuccessfully to open a nightclub on Sunset Boulevard in the old Writers Club building in 1940-1941 to be called the Duncan Sisters Music Hall. See my post here. LA Times 11/5/1942.

Hollywood Citizen News 8/11/1944.

On February 1, 1945, the Music Box reopened as a first-run motion picture theater, renamed the Guild Theater, operated by Fox West Coast. The gala grand opening was marked by searchlights over Hollywood Boulevard with bunting and pennants festooning the front of the building, which was remodeled for the new use. The opening fare was a double bill, “Bride By Mistake” and “The Falcon in Hollywood.”

Hollywood Citizen News 1/31/1945.

6126 Hollywood Boulevard would again be leased by CBS for radio broadcasts in 1948, when theaters in general, like nightclubs, were struggling to stay afloat. It resumed use as a movie theater on May 26, 1954 and was renamed Fox Theater aka New Fox. In September 1959 Pacific Theaters took over the operation, as it did the Marcal Theater, and the Fox was renamed the Pix Theater.

In 1985, the building returned to its legitimate theater roots and was renamed the Henry Fonda Theater. As the Fonda Theater, it continues as a theater venue today.

6021-6025 Hollywood Boulevard: The Marcal Theater

The Marcal Theater (also written as Mar-Cal), on the north side of Hollywood Boulevard at 6025 just West of the Brokaw property, opened on May 15, 1926. The name was a combination of two of its owners’ names: Screen actress Alice Calhoun and theater operator Mark M. Hansen.

Marinus Mark Hansen was born in Aalborg, Denmark in 1892. He came to the USA by way of Liverpool in March 1910 aboard the doomed ocean liner Lusitania, and settled briefly in Lostwood, North Dakota where he had an older brother, Carl, who had immigrated a few years earlier, and worked as a laborer taking odd jobs.

As of 1914 he was working as a saloon keeper in Madoc, Montana. By 1915 he also had a half-interest in the Lyceum Theatre in Scobey, Montana with partner Charles Peterson; Hansen sold his half-interest in November 1915.

Scobey Montana in 1917.

He married Ida R. Nelson in Plentywood, Montana on September 9, 1915. The couple’s first daughter was born at Madoc in 1916.

In May 1919 Hansen bought a former saloon in Scobey, which he converted into a bowling alley and cigar store.

The Scobey Citizen 12/25/1919

In August 1919, Hansen bought the Lyric Theater in Williston, North Dakota. He soon joined with local businessmen to build a second theater there, the Orpheum.

Williston, ND as it looked in Hansen’s time.

Within two years, the couple had moved to Minnesota, where Mark also had theater interests, and their second daughter was born in August 1921. Hansen sold his theaters in Blue Earth, Minnesota in September 1921.

Blue Earth, Minnesota in 1920.

In June 1922, the Hansens relocated to the Coast when Mark bought 3 theaters in Oxnard, California.

Oxnard in the 1920s.

Oxnard Press Courier 6/2/1922

A year and a half later, on March 19, 1924 it was announced that Hansen was moving to Los Angeles. It was here that he would finally settle permanently.

Hansen already owned three theaters in Los Angeles, including the Larchmont. At 149 N. Larchmont, it had opened in 1922 and was operated by Alice Calhoun. Hansen had become an owner by January 1924.

On July 10, 1925, the Hollywood Daily Citizen reported that Hansen and Calhoun had taken a 99 year lease on the Jewett property at 6025 Hollywood Boulevard where they would build an as-yet unnamed theater, to be designed by architect William Allen.

 

Hollywood Daily Citizen 7/10/1925

J.C. and Margaret O. Jewett had been living at this address, originally 541 Prospect Avenue, since circa 1906. Margaret Jewett was still living here through 1924 before relocating.

Detail of a 1913 Sanborn Fire Insurance map showing the Jewett property at 6025 Hollywood Boulevard. Library of Congress.

In August 1925, the Jewett ranch house and garage were moved from 6025 Hollywood Boulevard to 3090 St. George Street in the Los Feliz neighborhood. It appears to have survived at this location.

The former 6025 Hollywood Boulevard today. Google map image.

Although the July 10 report had stated construction was to begin within 60 days, ground breaking for the new theater did not happen until December 1, 1925- with Alice Calhoun operating the steam shovel herself.

Alice Calhoun (center) and Mark Hansen (lower right) around the time the Marcal Theater was proposed. Hollywood Daily Citizen 2/25/1926

Earlier reports stated that it was a 99-year lease. LA Times 12/2/1925

Sketch of the Marcal. William Allen was architect. LA Times 1/24/1926.

The completed theater had a gala grand opening on May 14, 1926 with a showing of “Skinner’s Dress Suit.” The stars of the picture, Laura La Plante and Reginald Denny (who would later be on the Boulevard with his hobby shop) made a personal appearance.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 5/15/1926

Hollywood Daily Citizen 5/14/1926

 

Looking east on Hollywood Boulevard from Gower when the Marcal was new. The theater can be seen near the large trees. LAPL photo.

The new theater was an independent theater, unaffiliated with any movie studio. Independents typically didn’t get to show first-run films made by the major studios until after they had finished their initial run at a studio-owned or affiliated theater.

The exterior lobby and ticket booth of Marcal Theater. USC photo.

The Marcal had barely been open six months when it closed for renovations. On January 1927, Hansen announced that effective January 27, 1927, it would change programs weekly and present only first-run films. It held another gala grand opening on that date to celebrate the post-renovation reopening with a premiere of “Remember” and the Lindsay Simons jazz orchestra

 

Hollywood Daily Citizen 1/26/1927

Hollywood Daily Citizen 1/26/1927

On September 30, 1927, Mark Hansen and employees of the Marcal were called to testify before the federal grand jury in its investigation of booking agent  T.R. Gardner, who was indicted on suspicion of having brought the Jack Dempsey/Gene Tunney fight film to Los Angeles from Chicago. The film had been showing at the Marcal.

It was illegal at the time to transport fight films across state lines. But everyone wanted to see the film of this fight- especially the 7th round and the infamous “long count.” The fight had taken place at Chicago’s Soldier Field on September 22, 1927, a rematch between the two fighters; Tunney had taken the heavyweight title away from Dempsey the year before (my post on that is here). Dempsey knocked Tunney down in the 7th round. It was a new rule that a fighter had until the count of 10 to get up after being knocked down and that the opponent was to retreat to a neutral corner. Dempsey stood over Tunney for several seconds; the referee did not begin the 10 second count until Dempsey went to a neutral corner, therefore giving Tunney that extra time to recover. At the end of the match, Tunney was declared the winner.

It was not illegal to show fight films in theaters, and despite the ad’s warning, there was no attempt to seize the film, which continued at the Marcal through October 3. For more information about fight films, see my post here.

Hansen also operated the Marquis Theater at 9038 Melrose Avenue at Doheny, It opened in November 1925. Hollywood Daily Citizen 9/30/1927.

Mentalist Pierre Brookhart was booked into the Marcal as an added feature following the run of the Dempsey-Tunney fight film. Hollywood Daily Citizen 10/3/1927.

In March 1928, Hansen announced that he was getting into the real estate business, with offices on the second floor of the Marcal (his theater company’s offices were also on the second floor). Hansen and his wife did for sure buy a number of Hollywood Boulevard properties, including 6028 and 6032 across the street and others in the 5800 block.

In December 1931, the Marcal celebrated its 5th birthday, with a cake from the Pig n’ Whistle cafe and in-person appearances by special guest stars. Hansen stated that the theater had hosted over 3 million patrons and had screened over 1200 feature films.

Hollywood Citizen News 12/16/1931

In December 1934, Hansen announced that he was leasing the operation of the Marcal Theater to Jay M. Sutton and Albert A. Galston of Galston & Sutton Theaters and retiring from the theater business, at least temporarily, to focus on running his new nightclubs.

Hollywood Citizen News 12/18/1934.

 

In the Summer of 1933, with national Prohibition on the way out (beer and wine sales were legalized in March 1933; spirits and hard liquor remained forbidden until full Repeal in December), Hansen opened the Cabin Club at 2914-2916 S. Western Avenue. On Halloween night 1933, he opened a second club, the 3 Little Pigs, at 335 N. La Brea. The theme was inspired by the smash hit Disney cartoon released that year.

Hollywood Citizen News 10/27/1933

 

LA Illustrated Daily News 10/15/1935.

On November 9, 1933, Hansen was arrested for failure to take out a license to sell alcohol (beer) at his clubs as well as failure to pay sales tax on alcohol sales. In July 1934 he was back in court facing charges by the State Board of Equalization (SBE), which regulated implementation of new State liquor laws after repeal of Prohibition, that he had failed to report to the SBE that he was selling beverages with greater than 3.2% alcohol within 1-1/2 miles of the Sawtelle Soldier’s Home, as the law required. With the laws in flux, such charges were fairly typical at the time. Hansen said her was endeavoring to operate his places in a legal manner and was allowed to continue in business.

Nightclubs typically have a high turnover, however, and Hansen’s career as a nightclub man did not last long. Both clubs appear to have changed hands by the end of 1936. 335 N. La Brea later became the infamous Pirate’s Den club. See my post on this address here.

LA Times 11/10/1933

 

While Hansen was busy with his nightclubs, Galston & Sutton steered the Marcal through difficult times as the economy slowly began to recover from the Great Depression. Many Hollywood theaters were dark several nights a week, or were leasing them out for radio broadcasts as the Movie Town became a Radio City (I discussed the Westward progress of radio in previous posts here and here.).

The Marcal “now under personal direction of Albert A. Galston.” There was free parking across the street because Mark Hansen owned several parcels there. Hollywood Daily Citizen 1/18/1935

In February 1935, the new management undertook another remodeling. It reopened February 24, 1935 with a 7 day celebratory “inaugural week” to usher in their new policy of lowered loge seat admission price for adults from 25 cents to 20 cents. Galston & Sutton would also institute a revival policy, showing films not seen in Hollywood theaters for several years- and always a double feature.

The Marcal Theater in April 1935 during the run of The Mighty Barnum.” LAPL photo.

 

Hollywood Citizen News 4/18/1935

In the Spring of 1939, Mark Hansen Theaters, Inc. was thrown into involuntary bankruptcy by creditors. Being a corporation, however, this simply meant that he reorganized and carried on.

In April 1940, Hansen sued Galston & Sutton, seeking to forfeit renewal of their lease. Galston and Sutton argued that the theater’s gross profit had increased by 50% under their management. The duo prevailed and the lease was renewed for 10 years. In May, their second theater, the Hawaii, would open a few doors down at 5939-5941.

In January 1947, Hansen would enter the annals of true crime infamy. The horribly mutilated corpse of a young woman was discovered in a vacant lot on January 15, 1947. She was soon identified through fingerprints as 22-year-old Elizabeth Short, who had been living in Hollywood on and off for several months. Police (and reporters) ran down hundreds of leads but no arrests were made. Just as the case seemed to go cold, someone mailed a package of Short’s belongings – the contents of her purse- to the Los Angeles Examiner.

LA Times 1/25/1947

One of the items was a small date book, known as a diary, that Short had been using as an address book. It was stamped on the cover with the name Mark M. Hansen and the year 1937. Questioned by police on January 25, Hansen said he knew Short “casually” through Ann Toth, a “friend.” Short and Toth assertedly rented rooms at Hansen’s home, 6024 Carlos Avenue, located on the block north of the Marcal. Toth, a bit player in the movies, had been questioned by police on January 17 and told them that Short had lived with her at 6024 Carlos Avenue for about 2 months starting in August 1946. Hansen told the authorities that the book had been black the last time he saw it and that Short must have taken it from his desk. He had last seen Short in November 1946, he said. He was eliminated as a suspect at the time. Amateur sleuths, with scant “evidence” have continued to speculate about his guilt in the case, which was never solved.

Hansen had occupied the Carlos Avenue residence since 1936 at least, along with his wife Ida and daughters though 1940 for sure, per the 1940 US Census. It was convenient to his offices in the Marcal Theater.

In the wee hours of June 25, 1948, the Marcal Theater caught fire. Hansen saw the flames from his Carlos Avenue home and called the fire department. The auditorium was extensively damage- $100,000 worth according to some papers, $75,000 in others.  Insurance covered the loss and the theater reopened- with a refurbishment and modernized projection and sound equipment- on March 31, 1949 with a revival of “San Francisco” starring Clark Gable and Jeanette McDonald, and the Marx Brothers comedy classic, “A Night at the Opera.” The gala event was broadcast on local television via Don Lee’s KTSL.

Hollywood Citizen News 6/26/1948

Television by now posed a threat to the movies as audiences stayed home. The reopening of the Marcal was broadcast over Don Lee’s KTSL. LA Times 3/30/1949

Later in 1949, Hansen became a part owner of the Florentine Gardens, just east of the Marcal, which reopened under his management on July 1. Two weeks later, on July 15, 1949, a young woman named Lola Titus shot Hansen at the Carlos Avenue home. He survived, telling police that Titus was mad because he wouldn’t hire her for a show at the Florentine Gardens. Titus’ explanation of a romantic entanglement seems more plausible. Florentine Gardens would be sold to the Hollywood Canteen Foundation by the end of 1950.

Newspaper reports of the incident stated that Hansen and Ida had been estranged for 20 years. If so, they had been living together at the Carlos Avenue home in 1940, at least. They would live together again, at 2274 Canyon Drive (Ida’s address in 1949) per the 1950 US Census. She may have been used to his dalliances with other women (see notes below).

Television In May to June 1950, the television show “Hollywood Amateur Hour” was broadcast from the Marcal on Saturday mornings over KIEV.

Hollywood Citizen News 5/12/1950

 

San Pedro News Pilot 9/25/1951

In September 1951, the Marcal Theater joined the Hawaii and Beverly Hills Music Hall theaters in filing an anti-trust lawsuit against 20th Century Fox Corp., National Theaters Corp., Loew’s Inc., Warner Brothers Pictures, Inc., Warner Brothers Pictures Distributing Company, Universal Film Exchanges, Inc., Paramount Pictures Corp., Columbia Pictures Corp., United Artists Corp., Fox West Coast Theater Corp., and the Fox West Coast Agency Corp., charging them with unfair distribution and exhibition practices. The suit mirrored an earlier federal lawsuit, which had ultimately prevailed after going all the way to the US Supreme Court, but was still in the process of finalizing its terms.

The Marcal struggled as a film venue, however and for a time ceased showing movies.

In April 1952 FilmCraft Productions used the Marcal Theater for television filming. A pilot for a new Mark Goodson-Bill Todman produced game show, “Two for the Money” was filmed there on June 5, 1952. Allen turned down the job of emcee but the show was picked up using a different host.  Excerpts of the pilot, with glimpses of the live audience in the Marcal auditorium, can be viewed here:

In December 1952, Hansen had a full stage constructed in the auditorium so that the theater could host legitimate theater. It’s first production, “The Merry Widow,” debuted on December 4, 1952 but was not well received. The French Postcard Review, an old Earl Carroll “girl review” style show opened on October 2, 1953. It was followed on November 24 by “Brooklyn USA,” a play about the mob’s Murder, Inc. It was poorly reviewed as well.

Films returned in early 1954. In February it screened the Billy Wilder hit Stalag 17. This was followed by the controversial film “Salt of the Earth.”

The LA Mirror 2/23/1954

LA Daily News 5/20/1954.

In November 1957, the theater was rented out to the People’s Church of Hollywood led by Nate Perry. In January 1958 through June 1958 it continued as a religious venue with evangelist Paul Cain conducting services here.

LA Times 11/16/1957

LA Mirror 1/18/1958.

In July 1958, the theater returned to hosting occasional live stage shows and the odd special-interest film. In 1959 it began showing films regularly again. In April 1960 it was reported that Hansen was mulling turning it into a legitimate playhouse but that didn’t happen.

The play The Innocents based on the Henry James novel “The Turn of the Screw” debuted at the Marcal on September 12, 1958 with poor reviews. Hollywood Citizen News 9/13/1958

The last shows screened at the Marcal were “Splendor in the Grass” on a double bill with Elvis in “Girls! Girls! Girls!” The fare opened June 5, 1963. The final show was June 9, 1963.

Hansen sold the Marcal to Pacific Theaters, who had it renovated inside and out by architect Carl Mohler. The facade of the theater was encapsulated by a modern screened effect and new signage was added. It reopened as The World Theater on July 3, 1963 with a screening of “Captain Sinbad” and “The Slave.” The Hawaii Theater was closing around this same time and became the new Hollywood headquarters of the Salvation Army.

Hollywood Citizen News 7/3/1963

Mark Hansen (far right) with reps from Pacific Theaters and Mayor Yorty’s office. Hollywood Citizen News 7/18/1963

An example of typical World Theater fare. Hollywood Citizen News 6/18/1964

Mark Hansen died in June 1964.

The World Theater operated into the 1980s. The facade was damaged in the 1994 Northridge Earthquake and while the building is extant, it has been significantly altered.

Notes:

Different sources (including his own crypt) cite different years for Hansen’s birth date. July 25, 1892, is what he used on his naturalization papers. He applied for citizenship in 1916.

“Used to his dalliances with other women”: In July 1936, an actress named Faith Norton sued Hansen for breach of promise; the case was decided in her favor in January 1937 but the court only awarded her $100 of the $125,000 she sought.

Carlos Avenue was a short street, north of Hollywood Boulevard between Argyle and Bronson. Originally it was even shorter and did not extend east of Gower except for a short stump for the First Presbyterian Church of Hollywood at Gower and Carlos until later. In 1947, newspapers sometimes referred to 6024 Carlos as an apartment, other times a bungalow. It was a small, 1-story, 7-room single-family residence designed by architect C.S. Albright in February 1915. It was demolished in 1973.

On November 14, 1947, gossip columnist May Mann reported that Nils T. Granlund (NTG), formerly of the Florentine Gardens,  and Mark Hansen were going to open a 12-story hotel on Hollywood Boulevard near Gower, with a cabaret on the roof. Construction was to begin “shortly.” This project never happened.

5959 Hollywood Boulevard: The Holly-Food Mart

Located at 5959 Hollywood Boulevard, the Holly-Food-Mart, also known as the Hollywood Food Mart was the second of four commercial structures to be built on the Brokaw ranch property- the first being the Palms Grill to the east, which had started construction shortly before this project was announced in February 1937. The  Florentine Gardens would open next door the following year, and the Hawaii Theater in 1939.

LA Times 2/7/1937

The owner of the former Brokaw property, the Times-Mirror Company, commissioned the building, designed by architect Arlos R. Sedgley (mistakenly identified as “A.B.” Sedgely in the Times article above), and leased it for use as a market. The Holly-Food Mart opened by September 1937.

Hollywood Citizen News 9/14/1937

The Holly-Food Mart c. 1937. LAPL photo

The Holly-Food Mart opening night, 1937. Like most LA markets at the time, the displays of fresh fruit and veg were placed out front. Reflections of the neon signs for the Nash (6028) and Pontiac (6032) dealerships across the street can be seen. LAPL photo.

The Holly-Food Mart at night, c.1937. The Marcal Theater at 6021-6025 can be seen. LAPL photo.

The Holly-Food Mart was a market for less than 10 years. Open through December 1945, starting in 1946, it took on other uses. For most of the 1950s and 1960s, the remodeled building served as the offices of a publishing firm.

In June 1970  it was converted into a two-screen (twin) theater called the Adam and Eve, which opened in July, specializing in adult films.

Sketch of the former Holly-Food Mart, converted to use as a theater. LA Times 7/19/1970

An example of the fare being screened at the Adam and Eve. LA Times 7/31/1970

In November 1974, 5959 Hollywood Boulevard became another adult movie house, the X, Theatre, notable for the giant neon X on its facade.

LA Times 11/1/1974.As the X Theater. The “X” movie rating came to be in 1968.

Hollywood Boulevard looking west from just east of Gower in 1986. 5959 as the X Theatre can be seen on the right. UCLA photo.

It remained the X Theatre longer than it was the Holly-Food Mart.

The much-altered building was demolished in 2016.

5939-5941 Hollywood Boulevard: The Hawaii Theater

The Hawaii Theater in May 1940. Umbrellas on the patio dining area of the Palms Grill can be seen in the center right. California State Library photo.

The Hawaii Theater opened on May 6, 1940. The last of 4 buildings constructed on the former Brokaw ranch property (the others were the Palms Grill at 5931-5937, the Hollywood Food Mart at 5959 and the Florentine Gardens cabaret restaurant at 5955), the theater, addressed initially as 5939 Hollywood Boulevard, was said to occupy the site of the ranch house itself.

Sketch of the proposed Hawaii Theater in the Los Angeles Times on November 19, 1939. The Times’ parent company owned the property that it would be built on.

On November 19, 1939, the property owner, the Times-Mirror Company, announced the project. Carl G. Moeller designed the streamline moderne-style 2-story building, which also housed two retail stores and office space, with supervising architect Clarence J. Smalle. The unfinished building was leased to Albert A. Galston and Jay M. Sutton of Galston & Sutton Theaters, who operated the Marcal Theater just up the block at 6025 Hollywood Boulevard. To be called the Hawaii Theater (it was peak Hawaiian craze, after all), it reflects a new era of theater building- not a movie palace but a neighborhood picture house. With seating for 1100 people, it featured a mezzanine in the “modern colonial” style with a children’s nursery (the Merry Melody room), complete with staffed attendant; a women’s reception room and powder room; a men’s lounge with a private smoking lounge next to the Projection Room; and the offices of Galston & Sutton, all of which would open onto a furnished 50-foot oval lobby.

At the “ground pouring” ceremony in December 1939, Harold Lloyd placed his signatire trademark round glasses in a block of wet cement, like at Graumann’s Chinese Theater up the block.

Hollywood Citizen News 12/30/1939

 

The Hawaii theater’s decor was, not surprisingly, Hawaiian. The auditorium was notable at the time for the use of blacklight illumination with fluorescent murals by Ruth Seeley.

LA News 5/6/1940

Auditorium of the Hawaii Theater in 1940. California State Library photo.

Citizens lined the Boulevard for the gala opening on May 6, 1940, which featured Hawaiian music, lights, stars, and, more importantly- free parking! Usherettes wore leis and “Hawiian-looking” outfits.

Most of the big-name stars were up the block at the Warner Theater for a preview of “Torrid Zone” with Ann Sheridan, James Cagney and Pat O’Brien. The Hawaii’s debut film was a reissue of “Abe Lincoln In Illinois,” which had premiered in Los Angeles in January 1940. The second feature was a first run film, The Courageous Dr. Christian,” with Jean Hersholt as the doctor, reprising his role in the popular Dr. Christian radio series (1937-1954).

Los Angeles News 5/6/1940

 

The Mill on the Floss and Isle of Destiny followed Abe Lincoln and Dr. Christian at the Hawaiian. LA Times 5/20/1940.

An independent theater at a time when many theaters were affiliated with, if not owned by, the major movie studios, the Hawaii was the first Los Angeles theater to land Gone With the Wind after the picture finally left the Carthay Circle Theater.

Gone With the Wind had been produced by an independent studio, Selznick International. MGM studio had netted distribution rights to the film as part of the king’s ransom David O. Selznick had to pay MGM (headed by his father-in-law, Louis B. Meyer), for the use of Clark Gable, who was under contract to MGM. The film had its world premiere in Atlanta December 14-16, 1939. It had its Los Angeles premiere at the Carthay Circle on December 28, 1939 and began its public run the following day at Carthay Circle and the United Artis Theater downtown. It remained at UA for 16 weeks and at the Carthay Circle for 24 weeks before closing its initial run on June 12, 1940. The film opened at the Carthay and US for a return engagement August 5-11, 1940 coinciding with the Hawaii Theater opening. The Hawaii Theater had to install benches on the street corners to accommodate all the Gone With the Wind fans arriving or leaving by streetcar or bus.

LA News 8/1/1940

The Hawaii Theater was primarily a second-run house, mostly showing films like Gone With the Wind, that had previously enjoyed an initial run at a major theater, or revivals of pictures that had not been on the screen in several years. Showmen Galston and Sutton often got creative with stunts and performance art “prologues” to fill the Hawaii’s 1100 seats. During the run of “Phantom Speaks,” which opened on Friday, April 13, 1945, for example, actor Loren Palmer would be “electrocuted” on the stage 5 times a day, then would subsequently run through the auditorium as the “electric ghost.”

Hollywood Citizen News 4/11/1945

In June 1945, it was reported that the San Francisco Music Hall theater chain had acquired 4 Los Angeles theater: The Hollywood at 6523 Hollywood Boulevard, the Los Angeles at 8th & Broadway, the Beverly Hills on Wilshire, and the Hawaii Theater. United Artist were partners in the organization, as were Sutton and Galston. Music Hall theaters would show mostly first-run films, starting with Ernie Pyle’s “The Story of G.I. Joe” on August 8, 1945

LA Daily News 8/6/1945

Howard Hughes’ long-delayed film “The Outlaw” finally went into general release in April 1946 and the Hawaii, as one of the Music Hall theaters, was one of the 4 places to see it in Los Angles. Was it a real stinkeroo? Yes. Did audiences flock to see it anyway? Also yes.

Hollywood Citizen News 3/30/1946

Hollywood Citizen News 4/4/1946

 

The Hawaii Theater in early February 1947 during the run of “The Chase” starring Robert Cummings. LAPL photo.

 

The Chase in its 2nd week at the Hawaii. LA Times 2/1/1947

 

With a general shortage of new films being produced in 1948, the Music Hall theaters, including the Hawaii, revived “Lost Horizon,” which had first been seen in 1937. The revival proved to be a huge hit.

Hollywood Citizen News 4/13/1948

In May 1948, the US Supreme Court ruled in favor of the federal government in an anti-trust lawsuit against the major film corporations, filed by the Department of Justice almost 10 full years earlier.

In July 1938, the DOJ sued Paramount Pictures, Inc., Loew’s Inc., the Irving Trust Co. (trustee for RKO Corp., then in bankruptcy), Warner Brothers Pictures, Inc., 20th Century Fox Film Corp., Columbia Pictures Corp., Universal Corp., and United Artists Corp., accusing the industry of violating the 1890 Sherman Anti-Trust Act. The suit was an outgrowth of complaints by small, independent theater operators, who felt that studio policies for motion picture distribution and exhibition were designed to drive them out of business or compel them to sell to studio-owned theaters. A similar suit had been filed in 1928 and the studios lost; however, as with attempts to regulate film content, the studios basically functioned as usual and in 1933 got the federal government to nullify the judgment under FDR’s new National industrial Recovery Act (itself declared unconstitutional in 1935). No doubt there were many late-night meetings about it over at the Meyer Building down the street.

LA Daily News 7/21/1938

A settlement in the 1938 suit was reached in June 1940, shortly after the indy Hawaii Theater opened. The studios were meant to comply with new distribution and exhibition rules by November 1943. The compliance did not happen and the DOJ went back to court. The case went to trial in October 1945 and the District court ruled in favor of the studios. The DOJ appealed to the US Supreme Court, which decided in favor of the government in May 1948. Each of the defendants entered into a consent decree with the DOJ- known as the “Paramount Decrees” – between 1949 and 1952. Among other things, the ruling meant studios could no longer both distribute films and own theaters without prior approval of the Court and outlawed the long -hated (by theater operators) practice of “block-booking” whereby a theater had to take all of a studio’s film offerings, stinkeroos included, not just the pipperoos it wanted.

Hollywood Citizen News 5/3/1948

The ruling is often cited as the cause of the breakup of the studio system. However, movie theaters, like nightclubs, were already struggling as audiences drifted to other past times. Tax figures, for example, showed movie theater and nightclub admissions were down 20% in 1948 compared to 1947. The huge dinner theater nightclub next door to the Hawaii, The Florentine Gardens, went bankrupt in 1948.

Hollywood Citizen News 3/30/1948

“The Golden Gloves Story,” released in May 1950, was one of the last first-run films to show at the Hawaii as part of the Music Hall theater chain.

A fifth Music Hall theater had been added to the chain- the Forum. LA Times 5/17/1950

The stars of “His Kind of Woman,” Robert Mitchum and Jane Russell, signed autographs in the lobby of the Hawaii Theater on August 31, 1951, the day the film opened at the Hawaii, the Orpheum and the El Rey. The Hawaii was no longer part of the Music Hall chain.

Hollywood Citizen News 8/31/1951

In September 1951, operators of the Hawaii Theater, the Marcal and the Beverly Hills Music Hall, filed an anti-trust lawsuit against 20th Century Fox Corp., National Theaters Corp., Loew’s Inc., Warner Brothers Pictures, Inc., Warner Brothers Pictures Distributing Company, Universal Film Exchanges, Inc., Paramount Pictures Corp., Columbia Pictures Corp., United Artists Corp., Fox West Coast Theater Corp., and the Fox West Coast Agency Corp., charging them with unfair distribution and exhibition practices. With the federal lawsuit also finalizing its terms, the lawsuit was successful. Films often began to open at the Hawaii concurrently with their runs at the major downtown theaters.

San Pedro News Pilot 9/25/1951

Paramount’s first-run When Worlds Collide debuted at the Hawaii Theater at the same time as it was showing downtown. Hollywood Citizen News 11/22/1951.

Theaters in general and independent theaters in particular, struggling in the early 50s to compete with television turned to new technology like CinemaScope, Filmorama, cycloramaic screens and 3D pictures to draw customers.

Jane Russel’s 3-D technicolor film The French Line came to the Hawaii on February 24, 1954. LA Mirror 2/23/1954.

Nothing could stop the changes happening to Hollywood Boulevard, however. Over the next decade, The Palms Grill next door closed. The Florentine Gardens and the Hollywood Food Mart became office buildings. The Mountain View Inn across the street was torn down.

The last film to screen at the Hawaii Theater was “Bye Bye Birdie.” The film opened at the Hawaii (and other theaters) on June 19, 1963 in wide release after finishing its held-over 11-week initial run at the Hollywood Paramount Theater.

LA Times 6/19/1963. “Bye Bye Birdie” played in wide release with “Dime With a Halo,” a comedy produced at the Hal Roach Studio.

The final showing of “Bye Bye Birdie” at the Hawaii Theater was June 23, 1963. Its doors closed after that.

LA Times 7/29/1963

“The invasion of Hollywood….” Hollywood Citizen News 10/14/1964

In July 1963 the Salvation Army took over the Hawaii Theater building as its new Hollywood headquarters. (The organization would also take over the vacant Palms Grill next door). The building’s interior was gutted and the exterior was substantially altered. The new headquarters held a grand opening October 16-18, 1964. The building is still extant, but unrecognizable.

Notes:

Sutton & Galston began operating the Marcal, taking a lease from owner Mark M. Hansen, in late December 1934. They continued to run it through 1941. In April 1940 Hansen sued to have their 10-year lease forfeited. The Marcal will have its own post.

5947 Hollywood Boulevard: The Brokaw Property

 

The Brokaw home at 5947 Hollywood Boulevard. LAPL photo.

The 2-story ranch home of John B. and Ida H. Brokaw, set amid lemon orchards, was located on 10 acres on the north side of Hollywood Boulevard (then Prospect Avenue) between Bronson and Gower extending north almost to Franklin. The residence was originally 539 E. Prospect Avenue; as of 1913 it was 5947 Hollywood Boulevard.

Brokaw, a buggy maker from Ohio, came to California on a visit in the 1880s and bought up 30 acres in the heart of Hollywood. He returned in 1892 and bout a 2-1/2 acre tract that he had planted with lemons; in 1894 he purchased the 10-acre tract that became the ranch home. Near the home, the Brokaws planted cypress and cedars and more exotic specimen trees and shrubs. The couple didn’t reside in Hollywood permanently, however, until after 1900; the 1900 US Census shows them still living in Ohio.

By 1901 Brokaw had decided to sell off his orchard property, other than the home ranch, in 1- to 3-acre tracts, through agent Alex Culver. The next year he would also sell tracts in Brokaw Tract #2, across the street from the family ranch on the south side of Hollywood Boulevard.

Ad for the first Brokaw Tract, along Hollywood Boulevard between Bronson and Gower, not including the family ranch parcel. LAT 11/17/1901.

 

The Brokaws did NOT move from the family ranch, however. In the 1910 US Census, they are at 539 E. Prospect, where John lists his profession as “rancher.”

Detail of the 1913 Sanborn Fire Insurance Company map showing the Brokaw home at 5947 Hollywood Boulevard.

Portion of a 1913 Sanborn Fire Insurance Company map showing the Brokaw ranch property at 5947 Hollywood Boulevard and some of the buildings built in the vicinity since the tracts were sold in 1-3 acre parcels starting in 1901. Library of Congress.

They were still living at the ranch, since re-addressed as 5947 Hollywood Boulevard, in the US census of 1920.

Excerpt of the 1920 US Census. National Archives.

 

In February 1921, Ida leased a 3-story brick building at 1320 S. Main Street in downtown Los Angeles to the Los Angeles Auto Engineering Company. In November 1921, John, the former buggy maker, announced the opening of his new auto body shop here.

LA Times 11/6/1921

 

On September 1, 1922 local papers blared the news of a gigantic 717-room. $6,000,000 hotel to be built in Hollywood on the Brokaw ranch property that would be known as the Hollywood-California Apartment Hotel. To be built by the Davenport Corporation, Noel Davenport told reporters he had secured a 99-year lease for the Brokaw ranch where the hotel would be built. Sketches of the mammoth project, by architect H. H Whiteley, were splashed across the front pages of the major local papers. It even made the mountains look small.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 9/1/1922.

 

On January 17, 1923, Davenport breathlessly announced that rather than leasing the property from Brokaw, the company had just completed paperwork to buy it outright. This was not true. The work of removing the old Brokaw residence would begin within 2-weeks, he said; the company would then build itself a 1-story admin structure and a month after that, excavation of the hotel would commence. None of this would happen, either. The Brokaw residence was not going anywhere anytime soon.

 

Hollywood Daily Citizen 1/17/1923

 

Ten months passed, then on November 13, 1923, the LA Times reported that the Davenports, “well-known Southern California hotel men” were building at 1002-room hotel on the Brokaw ranch house property. They wrote this as if it was the first time anyone was hearing about this project. Almost all details provided are verbatim from previous announcements. Work, they said, was to begin within 60 days and would be complete by the end of 1924.

LA Times 11/13/1923

LA Times 4/24/1924

Sixty days came and went. Nearly five months into 2024, Davenport announced that work on the $6,000,000 Hollywood-California Hotel would start within a few weeks (At least this time the paper acknowledged its previous reporting). Ads selling stock in the project, featuring a drawing of an entirely different building, sketched by architects Curlett & Beelman, appeared in local papers on May 5, 1924. Ida H. Brokaw was among the asserted board of directors.

LAT 5/5/1924

 

On May 22, the promoters held a presentation at the Jonathan Club. Curlett & Beelman showed of the plans. Finance director David A. Coleman said they’d sold a bond of $2,500,000 and almost half the preferred and common stock was subscribed.  June 15, 1924, yet another drawing of the $6,000,000 hotel appeared (again) in major local papers. Davenport said preliminary construction work was to begin the project the first of next week and dismantling of the Brokaw homestead was to start immediately. That did not happen.

LAT 6/15/1924

 

It’s the last we hear of the hotel on the Brokaw ranch property. In 1925, Brokaw was the victim of a swindle, also coincidentally involving a $6,000,000 project- in this case a fake railroad merger that burned many LA businessmen, bankers and politicians. The bunco artists behind the swindle. Thomas Hennessey and Harry D. Hibbs were exposed by Brokaw in May 1925. They were found guilty in September 1925. Brokaw’s investment was variously reported as $10,000, $30,000 and $100,000.

LA Times 5/8/1925

LA Time 5/8/1925

 

John Brokaw died, age 74, on August 9, 1926 at his ranch home at 5947 Hollywood Boulevard.

Hollywood Daily Citizen 8/10/1926.

The ranch house property became the subject of a lawsuit brought by Ida Brokaw against Guarantee Trust & Title Company, the executors of her late husband’s estate. The title company asserted that she had signed away her rights to the property in 1924 in a document conveying her share to her husband. Ida argued that she had not understood the document she signed. The court agreed on August 27, 1929,that Ida was the victim of fraud, and her signature on the document was the result of duress and undue influence.

 

LA Times 8/28/1929

Ida continued to live on the ranch property, with her brother Will C. Higgins, in 1930, when a 1-acre section of the grounds were made into a miniature golf course.

1930 US Census showing Ida Brokaw living at 5947 Hollywood Boulevard.

The miniature golf craze was at its height in the summer of 1930. Another old ranch property down the street at 5261-5263 Hollywod Boulevard had a course put in around the same time. Ralph B. Smith’s “Shady Greens” opened with the address 5937 Hollywood Boulevard on June 28, 1930. It did open the next season, 1931, but that was it.

“Golf in a Garden.” Shady Greens ad, 6/27/1930. Hollywood Daily Citizen.

In May 1932, the site opened as the Hollywood Garden Bridge Club, using a part of the gardens for outdoor bridge club gatherings. The club was founded by Mrs. Elaine Warren McIntire, who added an orchestra stage and toilets. Concrete pads installed for shuffleboard during Shady Greens’ run were used as a patio with a canvas canopy overhead.

LA Times 5/22/1932

Ida still lived at 5947 Hollywood Boulevard in 1931 and into 1932. Sometime between 1932 and early 1933, the property was acquired by the owner of the Los Angeles Times, the Times-Mirror Corp. and Ida moved out.

In 1933, the property served as an outdoor venue for the Los Angeles Kennel Club’s national dog show, addressed as 5945 Hollywood Boulevard- the only time this address was used. When the Los Angeles club hosted the event again in 1936, the address used was 5937.

Hollywood Citizen News 5/19/1933.

LA Times 5/4/1933

In December 1936 owner Times Mirror obtained a permit for a cafe building, to be built at 5931 Hollywood Boulevard. Designed by architect Gordon B. Kaufmann, it occupied part of the ranch property next to the concrete decks where the golf course/bridge club had served outdoor meals. The unfinished building was leased to William Klute for a cafe, to be known as the Palms Grill. (It has its own post here).

The Palms Grill c. 1937. Schultheis Collection, LAPL photo.

In February 1937, Times Mirror commissioned a building designed by architect A. B. Sedley, to be construction on the west end of the property, at 5959 Hollywood Boulevard. As with the Palms Grill, it was leased before construction began to a grocery store and would open as the Hollywood Food Mart (it will have its own post).

5959 Hollywod Boulevard as the Hollywood Food Mart, c. 1937. LAPL photo.

In November 1937, another project for the parcel was announced: the Florentine Gardens cabaret restaurant, to be constructed at 5955 Hollywood Boulevard. Also designed by Gordon B. Kaufman, it would open in December 1938 (it has its own post here).

Florentine Gardens at 5955 Hollywood Boulevard. LAPL photo.

the Brokaw ranch house was being used as a boarding house in its last years. A permit to demolish the residence was obtained on June 9, 1938.

Ad for the Brokaw ranch house. Hollywood Citizen-News 8/19/1936.

Finally, in November 1939, Times Mirror announced a theater was to be built on the last vacant part of the parcel, to be known as the Hawaii Theater. (It has its own post here).s 5939 Hollywood Boulevard, it reportedly occupied the site of the Brokaw ranch house itself.

Sketch of the proposed Hawaii Theater, 5939 Hollywood Boulevard. LA Times 11/19/1939

 

Notes:

Ida H. Brokaw was buying property in Los Angeles as of 1888. Even after moving from the ranch, she remained in the vicinity of her longtime home. In 1934-1936 she lived at 6060 Franklin Boulevard. By 1938 she was at 1781 Gower. In financial difficulties later, she spent her last years in an apartment with her brother at 1765 N. Vine. Her brother died in February 1948. Ida passed away in July 1948 at age 90.

Olive Day and the ‘Love Mart’ Case

Olive Day was the madam involved in the 1931 prostitution ring newspapers called the Love Mart/Love Market/Love Bazaar/Girl Bazaar. Like others before her and those still to come, the story played out the same way: lurid headlines, young girl victims’ parades for the photographers, a little black book containing the names of wealthy and/or famous men clients said to be shaking in their boots for fear of exposure (which never came), the madam is left holding the bag while the underworld bosses behind the operation are not charged (or even named) and simply start again with a fresh madam and new girls once the public outcry dies down.

Continue reading

The Orpheum Theater

Orpheum_theater_los_angelesThe first Orpheum Theater in Los Angeles had been only the second of the vaudeville circuit’s chain in the West when it opened in the former Child’s Opera House on Main Street in 1894. The newest Los Angeles Orpheum Theater opened in a grand new building in February 1926, the year vaudeville celebrated its 100th Anniversary. Continue reading

The Belasco Theater

Belasco_Theater_Los_AngelesIt was a double premiere- the opening of the new Belasco Theater at 11th & Hill streets and the Los Angeles debut of Gentlemen Prefer Blondes on November 1, 1926. Author Anita Loos and the crème de la crème of filmdom society were in attendance. Both the play and the theater were a hit. History doesn’t record whether the theater’s major financial backer enjoyed the show; he was about to leave for Washington, D.C. to testify in his bribery trial. Continue reading

Georges Carpentier in Los Angeles

georges-carpentierIn July 1921 Georges Carpenter and Jack Dempsey made history in the “Battle of the Century” for the world heavyweight title in Jersey City, NJ. Images of Carpentier lying prone on the canvas flashed from coast-to-coast almost instantaneously via the new press photo wire service. Five years later, in July 1926, Los Angeles finally got a look at the Orchid Man in the flesh. Continue reading